Sunday, January 26, 2014

Final judgment for filament producers

Comparing all machines brought some interesting insight, but judge for yourself.

Here is a judged comparison (for raw data see below).



Filabot Filastruder Extrusionbot Filafab
Price in € 475 205 460 850
Crusher In planning No No Yes
ABS Yes Yes Yes Yes
PLA Yes limited Yes Yes
Speed cm/min 12-50/1kg in 6.6h 15-60/1kg in 12h 60-91 120
Spooling No Yes +120€ Yes No
Kit/Assembled Kit Kit Assembled Assembled
Max 21 13 13 17 17
Red = 1 points; Yellow = 2 points; Green 3= points

Filabot:  Relatively high priced for its capabilities. For the same price the Extrusionbot looks much better.

Filastruder: The big plus here is the price however the specs show that this machine only covers the very basics and the PLA issue troubles me.

Extrusionbot: Has the best cost benefit ratio, combines a medium price with high extrusion speed and crusher and spooling are built in.

Filafab: Leads with some impressive speed, but is also double as expensive as all other models.




These are the raw data.



Filabot Filastruder Extrusionbot Filafab
Price in € 475 205 460 850
Crusher In planning No No Yes
ABS Yes Yes Yes Yes
PLA Yes limited Yes Yes
Speed cm/min 12-50/1kg in 6.6h 15-60/1kg in 12h 60-91/n.a. 120/n.a.
Spooling No Yes +120€ Yes No
Kit/Assembled Kit Kit Assembled Assembled

No comments:

Post a Comment